top of page

Nikita Kucherov Update: Reigning Hart Trophy Winner Requests Trade

Gabriel Emerick
Nov 12
4 min read

There is virtually never a doubt as to where the MVP of a major sports league will be playing the following season. But as of Friday October 30th, the landscape of the NHL will seemingly be undergoing serious changes. As initially reported by Elliotte Friedman, Tampa Bay Lightning superstar forward Nikita Kucherov has requested a trade out of Tampa Bay.


 Coming off of a 44 goal and 130 point season where he won the NHL’s Hart Memorial Trophy for the most valuable player in the league, the now 33 year old Kucherov entered this season going into the final year of his 8 year contract. Eligible to sign a contract extension on July 1st 2026, it was slightly surprising that Kucherov entered this season without signing an extension with the Lightning. 


However, there was still practically zero reason to think that he and the Lightning were on the verge of parting ways. Even with Kucherov having a slow start to this season for his standard, 15 points in 12 games prior to Friedman’s initial report, he remains one of the league’s top players. As a result leaving the organization with little desire to trade him. This is backed up by Lightning general manager Jullien BriseBois’ public statement where he sternly wrote “we unequivocally have no intention of trading Nikita”. 


In a post practice media scrum on Monday November 2nd Kucherov stated that his request stemmed from poor communication from Lightning management. In addition, he cited a believed lack of respect from the organization. He further added it has nothing to do with money or term on a potential contract extension. 


Now it's impossible to know for sure if this is entirely truthful, and with reports from Kevin Weeks and David Pagnotta about the supposed offers the team made the Kucherov, it is hard not to think that money and length of contract is not at least part of Kucherov’s displeasure. Weeks reports that the team’s initial offer was a contract of $13 million AAV (average annual value) and Pagnotta reports that this offer jumped to $15 million AAV on a 4 year extension in the wake of the major shifts in contract value that occurred this past offseason. This potential deal would be a significant raise from Kucherov’s current $9.5 million AAV current deal. However, with the NHL salary cap rising a significant amount next year and projected to continue to rise in the following years, the nature of player contracts are expected to change significantly. 


The beginning of this shift occurred this offseason with, headlined by Leo Carlsson who signed a deal worth $18 million AAV, Macklin Celebrini who signed for $18.8 million AAV, and Cale Makar signing for the maximum possible $20.4 million AAV. With the logic that Kucherov was the MVP of the league and thus should be paid as such, even a deal worth $15 million could easily be considered a significant underpayment. 


The other potential hang up has to do with contract length and Kucherov’s age. At 33 years old Kucherov is in somewhat of a weird spot, as historically at this age it would be consensus that his level of play should be expected to undergo a serious decline virtually any day now and that his career is nearly over. As a result, giving Kucherov any sort of long term contract would be absurd and totally out of the question. However, in recent years this idea has become somewhat outdated, players are playing longer and continuing to produce at an elite level well into their late 30s, now making a long term contract a legitimate possibility for Kucherov and something that he may think he undoubtedly deserves. 


While Kucherov may still have a bunch of years left in his career, if he were to be traded it is highly likely his preference would be to go to a team that is a clear Stanley Cup contender in the short term. Kucherov’s current contract gives him trade significant leverage throughout this situation, as he is allowed to submit a list of 10 teams that he would accept a trade to, (if the Lightning tried to trade him to one of the other 21 teams in the league he would have the ability to veto it). 


Lastly, the other piece to consider is the potential trade compensation that the Lightning feel they would need to receive in order to move Kucherov. As one of the very best players in the world Kucherov should seemingly require a significant trade package in order to be moved. However, as he is in the final year of his contract any team trading for him would almost certainly want to have an extension with Kucherov in place in order to make the trade. Combine the fact that he has clearly voiced he wants out makes it very tough to judge just how much other teams across the NHL would be willing to give up to acquire Kucherov. 


Ultimately, there are a lot of ways this situation could play out. At this point in time it is impossible to say with certainty what will happen, if Kucherov will actually be traded, and if so to where? Nikita Kucherov is one of the best players in hockey and I can say with extreme confidence that every single team would want to have him on their roster, but whether or not they have the means to make that happen is a different story.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page